When Time Isn’t Neutral: Paternal Age Over 50 and Fertility

Paternal age over 50 years decreases assisted reproductive technology (ART) success: a single UK center retrospective analysis. Morris G, Mavrelos D, Odia R, Viñals Gonzalez X, et al. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand 2021;100:1858–1867.

Retrospective cohort4,833 fresh IVF/ICSI cycles200 men aged 51+One London clinicOpen access
Observational

This study shows an association, not proof of cause. It could not adjust for the father’s health (such as BMI or smoking), sperm DNA damage or the cause of infertility.

Time isn’t neutral for men either

Fertility talk usually centres on women. This study looked at what happens when the male partner is older, using IVF and ICSI cycles with the couple’s own eggs.

33%lower odds of a live birth when the father was 51 or older, after accounting for the mother’s age
42%of men over 50 met WHO semen criteria, versus about 61% of younger men
Noindependent effect on miscarriage risk was found

What this does and doesn’t mean

It isn’t a cliff

Only men aged 51 and over showed a clear independent drop. Smaller differences in younger age groups were not statistically significant.

Parenthood is still possible

Live birth rates for men 51 and over were still 29.5% per cycle in this group. This is about planning and informed choices, not ruling anything out.

Her age still matters most

With a father aged 35 or under, the predicted chance of a live birth fell from 51.9% to 23.4% as the mother’s age rose from 35 or under to 40 and over.

Lab techniques have limits

ICSI was used in over 80% of cycles for men 51 and over, yet outcomes still fell. Techniques can bypass some barriers, but they can’t fully cancel out age-related sperm DNA damage.

Practical takeaways

Plan earlier

Understanding how both partners’ ages affect fertility helps you explore options sooner.

Talk honestly

Ask your care team what the evidence means for your own situation and expectations.

Who was included

ART cycles in the period
24,641
Excluding donor sperm
23,316
Semen source recorded
14,568
Fresh transfer performed
4,920
Included in analysis
4,833

December 2009 to August 2018. Excluded: donor oocytes, frozen or surgically retrieved sperm, stored-embryo cycles and PGT cycles. Included cycles involved 4,271 men.

Live birth rate by paternal age

Crude rate per cycle, before adjusting for the mother’s age.

≤35 years (n = 1,435)
48.9%
36–40 (n = 1,733)
41.0%
41–45 (n = 1,078)
34.5%
46–50 (n = 393)
31.8%
≥51 (n = 200)
29.5%

Maternal and paternal age were positively correlated (r = 0.494), so raw rates mix both effects. The adjusted analysis below separates them. Partners of men 51 and over were slightly younger (median 38 vs 39 years).

After adjusting for maternal age

Odds ratios against men aged 35 or under (reference = 1.000). Only the oldest group differed significantly.

Paternal ageLive birthClinical pregnancyMiscarriage
36–400.911 (0.783–1.060)0.908 (0.781–1.055)0.984 (0.771–1.254)
41–450.903 (0.751–1.09)0.861 (0.717–1.034)0.914 (0.682–1.226)
46–500.852 (0.660–1.101)0.817 (0.634–1.054)0.875 (0.580–1.318)
≥510.674 (0.482–0.943)p = 0.0210.643 (0.461–0.897)p = 0.0090.678 (0.369–1.250)p = 0.214, not significant

The reductions held across all maternal age groups, so a younger partner did not fully offset the effect. Miscarriage rose with maternal age, particularly from 38 (38–39: OR 1.542; 40 and over: OR 1.529), not with paternal age.

Predicted live birth rate

By maternal age (rows) and paternal age (columns). Darker green means a higher predicted rate.

Maternal ageFather ≤3536–4041–4546–50≥51
≤35 years51.9%49.5%49.3%47.9%42.1%
36–37 years45.7%43.4%43.1%41.8%36.2%
38–39 years37.1%34.9%34.7%33.4%28.4%
≥40 years23.4%21.8%21.6%20.6%17.1%

Semen quality and method

42.1%of men ≥51 met WHO criteria (56/133) vs 61.1% under 51, p = 0.001
82.5%of cycles used ICSI in men ≥51, vs about 51–56% in other groups
1.5 mLmedian volume in men ≥51, vs 2.8 mL in men ≤35

Concentration and motility were also lower in men 51 and over (median motility 50% vs 59%), while normal forms were unchanged. Semen parameters and insemination method were not retained as independent predictors of outcome, so lower basic semen quality, or ICSI use, did not explain the effect.

A possible mechanism

The authors point to sperm DNA fragmentation, which rises with age, with damage evident beyond about 45. They did not measure it in this study. ICSI has been reported to mitigate some of its effect. In the HABSelect trial, physiological ICSI did not improve live birth but reduced miscarriage. The authors call for work on the mechanism and on sperm selection techniques that might mitigate it.

How this fits the literature

Earlier studies conflicted, partly because many capped male age at 40 or used donor oocytes from younger women. This study includes 200 men aged 51 and over with the couple’s own eggs. A meta-analysis cited by the authors found a 43% higher miscarriage risk above age 45, although it was not limited to ART cycles. This study found no independent miscarriage effect.

Limits the authors note: retrospective and single-centre; paternal BMI, sperm DNA fragmentation, smoking, prior conceptions, comorbidities and cause of subfertility were not adjusted for; 39% of insemination cycles were excluded for lacking a fresh transfer, which may remove some younger high-responder couples. The authors conclude there should be a public health message for men not to delay fatherhood. Source: Morris et al., Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand 2021, doi:10.1111/aogs.14221. Casa Origen summarises research for information only; this is not medical advice.

Previous
Previous

Robertsonian Translocations: Hidden Causes of Miscarriage